Skip to content.
Skip to page navigation.Skip to content.Website accessibility
SF MTA homeSF MTA home SF MTA home
Page title as stylized text

Updates

The study has been completed and was presented to the SFMTA Board of Directors on November 6, 2012.

Full report, PDF

Full report, accessible version, PDF

About The Study

Purpose of the Study: to conduct an engineering feasibility analysis and supporting studies on transportation proposals in the Balboa Park (Better Neighborhoods) Station Area Plan and San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) and Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) station improvement plans, refine the long-range vision, and move short-range and mid-range projects toward implementation.    

Geneva Ave rendering from Balboa Park Station Area Plan (Better Neighborhoods Plan), showing pedestrian-filled wide plaza at station opposite residential buildings of several stores.

Above rendering from SF Planning Department: San Francisco General Plan: Balboa Park Station Area Plan

Scope and Goals

The study focuses on the BART/Muni transit station/yard functions and site plans, including potential joint development projects.  The study emphasizes:

  • improving the connections between the transit services at the Balboa Park Station,  and access to the station and transit stops,
  • enhancing safety and customer amenities,
  • reducing negative impacts of transportation facilities, and
  • supporting a vibrant community.

The study includes findings about existing and forecast conditions and preliminary recommendations for improvements 20 years into the future.  For selected “fast track” projects that can be implemented within the next several years, the study provides concept plans, preliminary cost estimates, project descriptions, and proposed schedules.

Balboa Park Station Capacity Study map
Balboa Park Station Capacity Study area map (PDF, 2.7MB)

Balboa Park Station Capacity Study area map (JPEG, 1.7MB)

Balboa Park Station Capacity Study area map accessible text description

Relationship to Other Plans

The study builds upon several other station area projects and is coordinated with other ongoing projects: 

The Balboa Park Station Area Plan was adopted as the official neighborhood land use and circulation plan by the Board of Supervisors in 2009.  Developed as part of the San Francisco Planning Department’s Better Neighborhoods Program, it discussed the need to improve connectivity and customer amenities around the station through the creation of a “transit station neighborhood.”  It proposed a number of major changes to the station area, including: a transit village on the Upper Yard and BART kiss and ride site near the southwest corner of the Geneva/San Jose intersection, decking over I-280 between Geneva and Ocean to improve station access and reduce freeway impacts, and reconfiguring the Geneva and Ocean freeway ramps.

Aerial photo of station area overlaid with rendering of I-280 deck, single point urban interchange,  with buildings on I-280 deck, Upper Yard and NW corner of Geneva/San Jose intersection.  Extensive trees on Ocean, Geneva, San Jose Avenues.glitch

BART’s Comprehensive Station Plan (2002) provided a vision for the station generally consistent with the City’s Station Area Plan.  However, it focused particularly on BART access improvements, such as improving the connection to Ocean Avenue.

The SFMTA’s Balboa Park Station Pedestrian and Bicycle Connection Project  (recently completed) is described in detail on the project web pages.

Consultants

  • Jacobs Engineering: prime consultant, transit analysis.
  • Fehr and Peers: traffic analysis, funding and implementation strategies.
  • CHS Consulting: intermodal, site circulation, parking.
  • MSA Design: structural engineering.

Funding:  Prop K Sales Tax, administered by the San Francisco County Transportation Authority.

SFMTA Project Manager: Frank Markowitz, Sustainable Streets Division, frank.markowitz@sfmta.com, 415.701.4500.

Community Outreach Highlights

Past Events

  • Community Meeting held on Wed. May 19, 2010, at Lick Wilmerding High School, focused on Fast Track Projects.
  • 2nd Community Meeting held on Oct. 6, 2010, at Lick Wilmerding High School, focused on mid/long-range projects.
  • Presentation to District 11 Neighborhood Council on Dec. 11, 2010.

Community Meeting - October 6, 2010

The meeting was attended by about 40 neighborhood residents and other interested citizens.  The meeting started with an introduction by District 11 Supervisor John Avalos.  Brief presentations followed by staff from SFMTA, BART, and the San Francisco County Transportation Authority.  Attendees then walked through several information/discussion stations, where they could voice opinions on specific issues.  They could also express their support or opposition to preliminary recommendations by voting on Improvement Priorities.

The presentation boards for each station were as follows:.

Citizens look at presentation boards and discuss projects at October 6, 2010 community meeting.Citizens view slide show and discuss projects at October 6, 2010 community meeting.Citizens view presentation boards and discuss projects at October 6, 2010 community meeting.

Balboa Park Station Capacity Study Improvement Priority Voting

The Improvement Priority voting results below showed strongest support for: Geneva Avenue transit plaza improvements, i.e., NextMuni/NextBART electronic signs, lighting improvements, canopies; an Upper Yard transit village; and pedestrian enhancements at the Ocean/Geneva/Phelan intersection.  The strongest concerns were expressed about the proposal to extend the J Line down San Jose Avenue to a new terminal on 19th Avenue near San Francisco State University and Stonestown, and move the M Line terminal from Balboa Park to 19th Avenue near Parkmerced.  This change would allow for the J and K line boarding areas to be separated, creating more boarding space for both lines. However, the J/M terminal move is no longer recommended by the Transit Effectiveness Project (TEP).

Note: improvements that are already under construction or funded and committed are not shown.

Key:

  • Short = Short-Range Time Frame, 1-5 years.
  • Mid = Mid-Range Time Frame, 6-10 years.
  • Long = Long-Range Time Frame, 11+ years.
  • Yes = Citizen responded "Yes, Like This Proposed Improvement"
  • No = Citizen responded "No, Don't Like This Proposal"

Proposed Improvement

Time Frame

Yes

No

Customer Amenities And Information

Geneva Transit Plaza: Bus Loading Areas near BART Entrances

Real time NextBus/BART Electronic Signs

Short

6

Canopies

Short

4

Lighting Improvements

Short

6

Geneva Avenue Transit Operations and Pedestrian Access

Reconfigure Westbound Lanes and Widen Sidewalks in Bus Loading Area and on North Side of I-280 Overpass

Short

1

0.5 (dot on line)

Reconfigure Kiss and Ride Roadway to Eliminate Exits/Entrances on Geneva Avenue

Short

3

2.5 (dot on line)

Ocean Avenue Transit and Bike Facilities

Complete Bike Lanes between Alemany Boulevard and Phelan Avenue

Long

4

Allow Buses to use Light Rail Track Westbound

Long

1

Provide New Westbound Stop at Station for 49, 29, 54 Routes

Short

3

Improve Ocean/Geneva/Phelan Intersection for Pedestrians using corner sidewalk extensions

Short

6

Light Rail Routes and Stops

To Create More Boarding Room, Move J Line out of loop, down San Jose Avenue. M Line no longer would serve Balboa Park.

Mid, Long

1

7

Provide Accessible, Convenient K Line Boarding near BART Mezzanine Entrance

Mid, Long

Move Final Northbound M Line Stop to North Side of San Jose/Geneva Intersection with Accessible Boarding Platforms

Short

3

Move J/K Boarding to New Accessible Platform on San Jose Avenue

Short

Remove Pinch Points on Walkway from BART to San Jose Avenue

Short

1

Freeway Interchange

Construct Elevated Kiss and Ride Roadway between I-280 and BART's Westside Walkway/New Entrance

Long

2

Transit-Oriented Development

Pursue Upper Yard Residential-Retail "Transit Village"

Mid, Long

6

3

Construct Small Retail Building between north Geneva Transit Plaza and Green Annex Building

Mid, Long

2

Other Accessibility Improvements

Straighten out I-280 Southbound Off-Ramp to T Intersection at Ocean; no high speed merge

Mid, Long

Install Flashing Beacon and Warning Sign at I-280 Southbound Off-Ramp

Short

1

Install Elevator on South Side of Geneva Avenue to BART

Short

4

 

Explore:

   
   

Skip bottom navigation and boilerplate text.Begin brief site navigation and boilerplate text.

telephone311 Free language assistance / 免費語言協助 / Ayuda gratuita con el idioma / Бесплатная помощь переводчиков / Trợ giúp Thông dịch Miễn phí / Assistance linguistique gratuite / 無料の言語支援 / 무료 언어 지원 / Libreng tulong para sa wikang Tagalog / คว“มช่วยเหลือท“งภ“ษ“โดยไม่เส’ยค่าใช้จ่าย