Skip to content.
Skip to page navigation.Skip to content.Web site accessibility
SF MTA homeSF MTA home SF MTA home
Page title as stylized text

Skip to proposals

Background

San Francisco voters passed Proposition A in the November 2007 election, giving the Board of Supervisors the option of transferring the powers of the Taxi Commission to the SFMTA.  The Board of Supervisors exercised that option; as of March 1, 2009, the Taxi Commission ceased to exist and the SFMTA has regulatory jurisdiction over the San Francisco taxi industry.

By passing Proposition A, the voters also created the possibility of reforming Proposition K, the 1978 ballot initiative that created the taxi medallion system that is in place today.

Under the Proposition K system, taxi medallions, which are permits to operate taxis in San Francisco, are issued by the City to a person and that person pays an annual permit fee. 

There are 1,500 taxi medallions currently authorized in the City.  The medallions are not transferable, and the medallion holder is required to drive a minimum number of hours every year in order to retain the right to keep the permit.  So long as the medallion holder meets the full-time driving requirements, he or she may also lease the medallion to other drivers for additional income.  If the medallion holder does not drive sufficient hours, the permit can be taken away by the City and given to the next person on the waiting list for a medallion.  There are currently more than 3,000 people on the waiting list for a taxi medallion, and it is not uncommon for a person to wait more than 15 years for their turn to get a taxi medallion.

There are features of the San Francisco taxi industry that could be improved.  For example, the industry lacks an exit strategy for career drivers, who may dedicate their working lives to the taxi industry without being able to build up assets sufficient to support retirement.  Because a person must surrender their medallion when they can no longer drive, medallion holders who are elderly or disabled must continue to drive or risk losing the medallion, which may be their sole source of income. 

The level of income of taxi drivers makes it difficult for drivers to afford health care or to be able to save for retirement.  Because they work as independent contractors in San Francisco, drivers do not have access to employer-based benefits.

It has been suggested that there are opportunities to improve the San Francisco taxi industry through reform of Proposition K. In addition, there may be opportunities to generate revenue for the City through taxi medallion sales.  The SFMTA is hosting a process to explore the options for Proposition K reform.  The goal is to identify alternatives that would meet the needs of the taxi industry while generating revenue for the City.

The SFMTA requested proposals from the public and the taxi industry for creative options to reform the taxi medallion system in San Francisco.

Proposals for Proposition K reform

Proposals that have been received by the SFMTA are posted in this section.

For assistance with documents which are not accessible, please contact Christiane Hayashi, Director, Taxis and Accessible Services, at 415.701.5235. Some documents are scanned and processed using Optical Character Recognition (OCR) in order to attempt a text conversion; please see the OCR disclaimer.

All proposals are online as PDF files. PDF help

Short name

Name of Submitter

Title of Submission

Date Submitted

Proposal Accessibility

Aryan

Sam Aryan, Medallion Holder

New Policy Proposal: Proposed Policy for Auctioning Medallions

4/12/2007

Accessible

Asian Law Caucus

Asian Law Caucus/ United Taxicab Worker

Protecting Taxi Workers and San Francisco Consumers: Medallion Transferability and Proposition K

3/9/2009

Accessible

Bolig

Jane Bolig, Medallion Holder

ESOP: A Radically Gradual Proposal

3/9/2009

Accessible

Browne

Brian Browne, Economic Consultant

A New Approach to Allocating Taxicab Medallions in San Francisco: The New Proposition K

2006

Tagged

Carvelli - 1 of  3

Giuseppe Carvelli, Medallion Holder

Restoring Pride in the Taxi Industry-Medallion Ownership-Taxi Service in San Francisco

11/2009

Accessible

Carvelli - 2 of  3

Giuseppe Carvelli, Medallion Holder

Email correspondence to Christian Hayashi re:Taxi Medallions and Prop K Reforms

4/15/2009

OCR

Carvelli - 3 of 3

Giuseppe Carvelli, Medallion Holder

Proposal and Financial Worksheet for the Taxi Industry Reform

11/2009

OCR

Cesana

Robert Cesana

Suggestion from Robert Cesana

2/7/2009

OCR

Charter

Charter Reform Working Group

Memorandum to Working Group Members from Jordanna Thigpen Re: Submissions by Working Group Members

7/11/2008

OCR

Committee

City Services Committee(Matt Gonzalez, Chris Daly; July 28, 2004

Taxi Permit Reform Initiative

7/28/2004

OCR

J. Diesso

John Diesso

Email correspondence to Christiane Hayashi re:argument for transferability of San Francisco Taxi Medallions and Outline to Implement

5/30/2009

Accessible

T. Diesso

Thomas Diesso

Transferability of Medallions

OCR

Donnelly

Tim Donnelly

Taxi Medallion Proposal

OCR

Ferguson - 1 of 2

Michael Ferguson. Medallion Holder

Proposition K Reform Proposals and the San Francisco Taxi Industry

4/22/2009

OCR

Ferguson - 2 of 2

Michael Ferguson. Medallion Holder

Remarks on the Transferability of Taxi Medallions in the San Francisco Taxi Industry

11/23/2009

Accessible

Fogel

Richard Fogel, Medallion Holder

Letter to Mayor Gavin Newsom

07/2009

OCR

Fulkerson

Christopher Fulkerson

Letter to Christiane Hayashi

11/22/2009

OCR

Ghebremichael

Beraki Ghebremichael

Email Correspondence to Christiane Hayashi re:Proposals to improve Prop K

4/14/2009

Accessible

Goldman

Richard and Rhoda Goldman School of Public Policy, University of California, Berkeley

The San Francisco Taxicab Industry: An Equity Analysis

06/2006

Not accessible

Graffis

Ruach Graffis

Service and Fairness: A Plan for Reshaping Proposition K and Restructuring San Francisco's Taxi Industry with the Rider, Driver and Cab Company in Mind

11/24/2009

OCR

Han

John Han, Taxi Driver

Proposal on Taxi Reform

11/2009

Accessible

Hawkins

Charles Hawkins, Medallion Holder

Re: Comments on Prop K Discussion

11/18/2009

Accessible

Hazelkorn

Bud Hazelkorn, United Taxicab Workers

Email correspondence to SFMTA Board of Directors re: Why privatizing medallions is a wrong idea 4/9/2009

4/9/2009

Accessible

Healy

Ed Healy, Medallion Holder

Notes Toward a Compromise Transferability Plan

04/2009

OCR

Kennedy

Jim Kennedy, Medallion Holder

Email correspondence to Mayor Newsom re: BOS Rules Committee

3/27/2009

Accessible

Kirby

Peter Kirby, Taxi Driver

Email correspondence to SF Taxi Commission re: SF taxi business suggestions

3/19/2009

Accessible

Korengold - 1 of 4

Barry Korengold

Driver Investment Fund

6/8/2008

OCR

Korengold - 2 of 4

Barry Korengold

Prop K Charter Reform Proposal

1/27/2009

Accessible

Korengold - 3 of 4

Barry Korengold

Charter Reform Proposal

4/30/2009

OCR

Korengold - 4 of 4

Barry Korengold

San Francisco Cab Drivers' Association Criteria for a Compromise

11/22/2009

OCR

Korkos

Dennis Korkos, Medallion Holder

The Korkos Plan

11/27/2009

OCR

Lembke - 1 of 2

Art Lembke, Medallion Holder

Letter to Members of Taxi Commission and attachments, (1.4MB)

OCR

Lembke - 2 of 2

Art Lembke, Medallion Holder

Consolidated email correspondence to Christiane Hayashi

9/30/2009, 11/24/2009

Accessible

Little

Naomi Little. Executive Director, former San Francisco Taxi Commission

Proposal to Reform Proposition K (1978)

04/2004

OCR

Luxor

Luxor Cab Co.

A Plan to Revise San Francisco's Taxi Medallion System

02/2009

Accessible

McMurdo - 1 of 2

Carl McMurdo, Medallion Holders' Association

Proposal for medallion auction system made to Charter Reform Committee

03/2008

Accessible

McMurdo - 2 of 2

Carl McMurdo, Medallion Holders' Association

Plan Allowing for Purchases, Sales and Transfers of Taxi medallions

11/2009

Accessible

Moles

Richard Moles, Taxi Driver

Taxi Medallion and Traffic Suggestions

11/19/2009

OCR

Newsham

Brad Newsham

Email correspondence to SFMTA Board of Directors re:How to Raise $20 million from the taxi industry quickly

4/9/2009

Accessible

Quinn

Joseph Quinn

Email Correspondance to Chris Hayashi re:Proposed Transferable Taxi Medallions

1/6/2009, 4/6/2009

Accessible

Rebelos

Athan Rebelos

Medallion Reform Proposal

11/23/2009

OCR

Royal

Royal Taxi

Proposal for Permit Regulation

9/17/2008

Accessible

SFDNH

sftaxidriverneedhelp@gmail.com

Medallion Holders are Victims!!!

04/2009

OCR

Shannon

Patrick Shannon, Medallion Holder

SF Plan

4/30/2009

OCR

United

United Taxicab Workers

Building Upon the Prop K System to Improve the Lives of Cab Drivers and Better Service the Public

11/23/2009

OCR

Williams - 1 of 2

Michael Williams, Medallion Holder

The Egg Sucking Weasel of Yore

11/5/2009

OCR

Williams - 2 of 2

Michael Williams, Medallion Holder

The Red-Eye to Shangrila

11/24/2009

OCR

Wolter

Ron Wolter, Medallion Holder

Letters to Christiane Hayashi

3/27/2009, 12/21/09

OCR

Yellow - 1 of 2

Yellow Cab Coop. Inc.

Ordinance Providing for Reguatlions of Taxicabs Operations

Unknown

Accessible
Yellow - 2 of 2 Yellow Cab Coop. Inc. SFMTA
Taxi Industry Reform: Revenues from Permit Issuance and Transfer
Unknown Tagged presentation

 

   
   

Skip bottom navigation and boilerplate text.Begin brief site navigation and boilerplate text.